This was the first case that we chose to do, given the other good reviews. My husband and I enjoyed solving this, and we made use of the hints on the site to helo guide us at some points. I do however, feel that the answer at the end came out of nowhere. !!!!!SPOILER ALERT!!!!! There was no indication of who the actual original murderer was, and I felt it came out of nowhere because the person was barely mentioned before. I feel that the creators should add some more information about the suspects families, and connections to different places. This woukd have made it slightly clearer as to who the murderer was. There was also a victim that had very little focus on him, and I felt he was a very important part of the case because his murder is the reason for the others! More information should have been given on his murder.